Twitter’s Statement About How They Don’t Shadow Ban Kinda Sounds Like They Shadow Ban | Последние новости сегодня в мире культуры



Twitter’s Statement About How They Don’t Shadow Ban Kinda Sounds Like They Shadow Ban
Twitter’s Statement About How They Don’t Shadow Ban Kinda Sounds Like They Shadow Ban

While others are distracted by recent news that the U.S. economy grew by 4.1% this quarter, or that Donald Trump’s once-loyal lawyer now claims, without evidence, that the then-presidential candidate was aware his son was meeting with Russians for dirt on Hillary Clinton (which Trump continues to deny), or that Russian hackers appear to have …

While others are distracted by recent news that the U.S. economy grew by 4.1% this quarter, or that Donald Trumps once-loyal lawyer now claims, without evidence, that the then-presidential candidate was aware his son was meeting with Russians for dirt on Hillary Clinton (which Trump continues to deny), or that Russian hackers appear to have targeted the first candidate in the 2018 cycle, its easy to miss the most important question of the day: Is Twitter being unfair to conservatives??? VICE News first noticed that several prominent Republicans. such as RNC Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel and congressmen like Matt Gaetz and Mark Meadows, were not appearing in Twitters search box even when their full names were typed out. That effectively lumped in Republican politicians with figures like white supremacists Richard Spencer and Laura Loomer and alt-right Pizzagater Mike Cernovich. By contrast, none of their Democratic counterparts were affected. After the story went up, several conservative journalists noticed their accounts were also affected. Lol. Apparently I am also shadow banned despite being the only verified "Saagar" on twitter pic.twitter.com/0W3UC7P6e4 — Saagar Enjeti (@esaagar) July 25, 2018 According to some Twitter friends I am also shadow banned from the Twitter search bar. I’d be very grateful if @twitter could point me to any instances where I violated terms of service. — Amber Athey (@amber_athey) July 25, 2018 The issue was fixed, but Twitter soon after put out a statement denying that it was "shadow banning" users, the phrase VICE used. "People are asking us if we shadow ban. We do not…" the tech company writes. "And we certainly don’t shadow ban based on political viewpoints or ideology." But then the statement contains this admission of something Twitter has long been accused of. "We do not shadow ban. You are always able to see the tweets from accounts you follow (although you may have to do more work to find them, like go directly to their profile)." [Emphasis added] Uh, call me crazy, but that parenthetical sounds a lot like an admission that Twitter effectively shadow bans users. The problem is that both sides of the conversation are talking past each other, because no one can agree on what "shadow ban" means. In the early days of Internet forums, "shadow ban" was a term that meant a user could still post and see other peoples posts, but secretly other users could not see their activity. They werent banned from the forum, but as far as the other users were concerned, the "shadow banned" user simply didnt exist at all. Based on that definition, there have been a series of tut-tut pieces about how of course Twitter doesnt "shadow ban" and conservatives are freaking out over nothing. Its also the definition Twitter uses. "The best definition we found is this: deliberately making someone’s content undiscoverable to everyone except the person who posted it, unbeknownst to the original poster," they write. That strict definition was useful in the days when post visibility was basically the only way users engaged with each other. If you wanted to talk about a subject, you had to navigate through a forum, click on a post, and browse through the replies to see what people were saying. In those days, making someones posts completely undiscoverable was the only way to "shadow ban" someone. But social media is used so much differently. The bulk of Twitter users dont seek out individual accounts and scroll through their tweets. The entire point of Twitter is that by tweeting and retweeting, you place yourself and others on your followers newsfeeds. By tagging or replying to someone, you place yourself in their mentions. By using a hashtag, you make your tweet visible to people who are interested in searching for that subject. If, as Twitter admits, I can willingly choose to follow someone and not see any of their tweets unless I actively seek out their profile (and after their name not showing up in the search recommendations), then for all intents and purposes they have been banned from participating in Twitter the way 99.9% of users use the platform. Call it a florp, call it a bifworz, call it what you please. If a person is de facto banned from joining the conversation and isnt informed of that fact, "shadow ban" seems like a perfectly fine shorthand to me, prescriptivism and pedantry be damned. Twitter is of course at perfect liberty to shadow ban, or ban for that matter, anyone they please. And for what its worth, Im inclined to believe that the search bug disproportionately affecting conservatives was probably unintentionally. But the explanation for how it came about is a bit vague. For the most part, we believe the issue had more to do with how other people were interacting with these representatives’ accounts than the accounts themselves… There are communities that try to boost each other’s presence on the platform through coordinated engagement. We believe these types of actors engaged with the representatives’ accounts– the impact of this coordinated behavior, in combination with our implementation of search auto-suggestions, caused the representatives’ accounts to not show up in auto-suggestions. In addition to fixing search yesterday, we’re continuing to improve our system so it can better detect these situations and correct for them. If Twitter was disfavoring certain accounts based on how other accounts interact with them, that isnt ideal. Speaking for myself, Ive had tweets go viral on the alt-right simply because they were critical of campus liberals. Ive also been placed on mass blocklists that users can subscribe to and preemptively block anyone who expresses a thoughtcrime. Im sure you can tell from my opening paragraph that I recognize that this ranks pretty low in matters of importance. But millions of people use Twitter everyday, and the platform sometimes rivals television and traditional news outlets in its cultural power. If Twitter wants to hold onto that power, alienating half of Americans and lame excuses doesnt seem like a great way of going about it.
    2018-07-27 19:06:04


Картина Бэнкси, которая самоуничтожилась, получила новое навзание
Картина Бэнкси, которая самоуничтожилась, получила новое навзание
На новое название Бэнкси вдохновила песня Джона Пола Янга Love is in the Air (Любовь в воздухе).
    2018-10-14 18:33:20


Shredding Banksy: Can his fans do it better?
Shredding Banksy: Can his fans do it better?
Our own Banksy finds out what people outside Sothebys think of the headline-hitting stunt.
    2018-10-14 13:34:29


Strictly kiss: Professional dancer Katya in the wrong
Strictly kiss: Professional dancer Katya in the wrong
Judge Craig Revel Horwood says the pro-dancer should never have allowed it to happen.
    2018-10-13 15:34:05


Emma Rice: Im protective of myself after this time
Emma Rice: Im protective of myself after this time
But, the theatre director says, she avoids reading them to protect her artistic freedom.
    2018-10-13 03:05:02


Amy Winehouse hologram to tour worldwide next year
Amy Winehouse hologram to tour worldwide next year
The singer died aged 27 in 2011 after drug, alcohol and eating disorder issues.
    2018-10-13 03:04:59


Woman to keep shredded Banksy Girl With Balloon painting
Woman to keep shredded Banksy Girl With Balloon painting
The anonymous European woman who bought the Girl With Balloon painting will pay the £1m price.
    2018-10-13 03:04:55


Strictly couple apologise for kiss
Strictly couple apologise for kiss
The pair apologise on Strictly Come Dancing: It Takes Two, after being caught kissing in public.
    2018-10-13 03:04:51


Director Steve McQueen: Why I chose to remake 1980s TV hit Widows
Director Steve McQueen: Why I chose to remake 1980s TV hit Widows
Widows, the 1980s Lynda La Plante TV hit, has been remade for the big screen by 12 Years A Slave director Steve McQueen.
    2018-10-13 03:04:47


Festival organised in honour of disabled teenager
Festival organised in honour of disabled teenager
Unable to attend mainstream festivals, a 16-year-old girl has one organised in her honour.
    2018-10-13 03:04:41


How BTS help fans with their mental health
How BTS help fans with their mental health
As the K-pop sensation perform their first ever UK shows, we met them backstage at the O2 Arena.
    2018-10-13 03:04:36


Seann and Katya must do Strictly dance of shame
Seann and Katya must do Strictly dance of shame
Judge Craig Revel Horwood says beleaguered pair should get on with the job on the next live show.
    2018-10-13 03:04:32


Johnny Depp felt bad for JK Rowling over casting backlash
Johnny Depp felt bad for JK Rowling over casting backlash
The star says Rowling stuck by him amid domestic violence claims because she has seen the evidence.
    2018-10-13 03:04:24


Tilda Swinton admits playing old man in Suspiria film hoax
Tilda Swinton admits playing old man in Suspiria film hoax
The actress finally admits she wore prosthetics to pose as an 82-year-old man in her new film.
    2018-10-13 03:04:21


Poet laureate takes aim at Trump and Brexit
Poet laureate takes aim at Trump and Brexit
Carol Ann Duffys last collection as poet laureate sees her take aim at Brexit and Donald Trump.
    2018-10-13 03:04:17


Hannah Berry: New UK comics laureate to harness untapped potential
Hannah Berry: New UK comics laureate to harness untapped potential
Hannah Berry says she wants to spread her love of language through comics and graphic novels.
    2018-10-13 03:04:14


Cara Delevingnes top hat and other Royal wedding moments
Cara Delevingnes top hat and other Royal wedding moments
Knock-you-off-your-feet winds and Prince George giggling in the chapel - here are some lesser-spotted moments from the big day.
    2018-10-13 03:04:11


Charli XCX and Troye Sivans 1999 video is a huge throwback
Charli XCX and Troye Sivans 1999 video is a huge throwback
The British pop singers video with Troye Sivan for their new single 1999 is full of 90s nostalgia.
    2018-10-13 03:04:07


Kim Tate returns to Emmerdale for good
Kim Tate returns to Emmerdale for good
The veteran baddie, played by Claire King, is returning to the soap for good after her recent cameo.
    2018-10-13 03:04:04


The cream of Manchesters music revolution
The cream of Manchesters music revolution
From Oasis to IAMDBB, an exhibition explores the acts who defined how Manchester is seen by the world.
    2018-10-12 20:34:52


Netflix: The signs you might need a break from the site
Netflix: The signs you might need a break from the site
A handy guide on the telltale clues you might need a break from the streaming service.
    2018-10-12 20:34:46


The TV drama thats a game-changer for trans people
The TV drama thats a game-changer for trans people
The drama about a trans gender child is applauded by campaigners but its producers expect a backlash.
    2018-10-12 20:34:20


Thieves steal 50 David Gilbert sculptures during Liverpool break-in
Thieves steal 50 David Gilbert sculptures during Liverpool break-in
The works were worth about £150,000 and are irreplaceable, an art trust chairman says.
    2018-10-12 13:05:06


Should Seann Walsh stay on Strictly?
Should Seann Walsh stay on Strictly?
The dance couple have made headlines for all the wrong reasons - so what should happen now?
    2018-10-10 17:08:24


Bill Turnbull on cancer: For heavens sake, get tested
Bill Turnbull on cancer: For heavens sake, get tested
Former BBC Breakfast presenter Bill Turnbull gives an update on his cancer treatment.
    2018-10-10 17:08:06


Katie Price arrested on suspicion of drink-driving
Katie Price arrested on suspicion of drink-driving
Police found the former glamour model inside a damaged car stopped on a roadside in south-east London.
    2018-10-10 17:07:56


The Circles Dan: I was furious about catfishing
The Circles Dan: I was furious about catfishing
Dan from The Circle said he felt furious and humiliated after he was catfished by Alex.
    2018-10-10 13:35:11


Rihanna and other celebs urging fans to register to vote
Rihanna and other celebs urging fans to register to vote
Celebrities have been getting political on social media ahead of the US mid term elections in November.
    2018-10-10 13:34:51


A Star Is Born: Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper film not in Vue cinemas
A Star Is Born: Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper film not in Vue cinemas
Warner Bros. and Vue say they are working hard to come to an agreement.
    2018-10-10 13:05:21


Ruby Rose seen in first Batwoman picture
Ruby Rose seen in first Batwoman picture
The Australian star is seen in her superhero costume as filming begins on her introductory episodes.
    2018-10-10 12:04:00

Что будем читать?

Список новостей
Прокрутить вверх